Alias Grace by Margaret Atwood
Published: 1996
Alias Grace by Margaret Atwood is the fictionalized story of a true crime.
Facts. Grace Martin and James McDermott were found guilty of murdering Thomas Kinnear and his housekeeper/mistress Nancy Montgomery in Canada in 1843. James McDermott was hanged for the crime. Grace, then 16, was sentenced to life in prison in Kingston Ontario, and sent to an insane asylum in Toronto for a time. Her lawyer had argued that because of her youth and weak gender (being female), not to mention her lack of intelligence (close to being a complete idiot- or so it was said), Grace should not be so harshly punished. Atwood first read about the crime in a book written by Susanna Moodie, who retold the story from a third hand account, and Atwood questioned some (but not all) of the details. After much research into the available records, newspaper accounts and the overall political and social era, she wrote Alias Grace.
Atwood combines fact and fiction to tell Grace’s story by developing the character of Dr. Simon Jordan, who is researching mental illness and insane asylums, and who ends up visiting Grace eight years after her incarceration. Her story slowly (very slowly) comes out, and whether fact or fiction, is quite entertaining. Some think her innocent (or just naïve), and some think Grace is insane. Grace says she cannot remember what happened, and Dr. Jordan tries to bring back her memories. What he finds sends him into his own nightmare.
Atwood takes us on a journey through Grace’s memories, but also through the mind of her doctor, who is slowly losing both his morals and perhaps a bit of his mind.
Although I am not a “historical fiction” reader, I found this book very interesting, probably because it is centered in Ontario, where I live, and I recognized the towns, cities and political names mentioned.
But whatever you believe, Grace is a strong woman, who has seen much, and whose thoughts are quite deep. As usual, Margaret Atwood wrote a strong character. It is left up to the reader to determine what to believe. Victim or fiend?
While I enjoyed the book, I did find it long!
Read: August 2017
Favorite Quotes from Alias Grace:
“Sometimes at night I whisper it over to myself: Murderess, Murderess.”
“I am fond of animals as a rule but this one took an effort.”
“Gone mad is what they say, and sometimes Run mad, as if mad is a direction, like west; as if mad is a different house you could step into, or a separate country entirely. But when you go mad you don’t go any other place, you stay where you are. And somebody else comes in.”
“Those who have been in trouble themselves are alert to it in others, Sir.”
“If we were all on trial for our thoughts, we would all be hanged.”
About the Author: Margaret Atwood (1939- ) is a renowned Canadian author. She is the author of more than thirty-five volumes of poetry, children’s literature, fiction, and non-fiction and is perhaps best known for her novels – including The Handmaid’s Tale. She currently lives in Toronto. (p.s. If nothing else, we share a birthday)